The production of weapons of mass destruction has always been associated with economic "waste." The term is pejorative, since it implies a failure of function. But no human activity can properly be considered wasteful if it achieves its contextual objective. The phrase "wasteful but necessary," applied not only to war expenditures, but to most of the "unproductive" commercial activities of our society, is a contradiction in terms.
"... The attacks that have since the time of Samuel’s criticism of King Saul been leveled against military expenditures as waste may well have concealed or misunderstood the point that some kinds of waste may have a larger social utility." [13]
In the case of military "waste," there is indeed a larger social utility. It derives from the fact that the "wastefulness" of war production is exercised entirely outside the framework of the economy of supply and demand. As such, it provides the only critically large segment of the total economy that is subject to complete and arbitrary central control. If modern industrial societies can be defined as those which have developed the capacity to produce more than is required for their economic survival (regardless of the equities of distribution of goods within them), military spending can be said to furnish the only balance wheel with sufficient inertia to stabilize the advance of their economies. The fact that war is "wasteful" is what enables it to serve this function. And the faster the economy advances, the heavier this balance wheel must be.
Men play at tragedy because they do not believe in the reality of the tragedy which is actually being staged in the civilized world.
3 comments:
mr.b, a few years ago you asked if anyone had a convincing argument to be a vegetarian... well I finally found the one that's convinced me and I think you would find it intriguing. It's 2 documentaries:
**Healing Cancer by Mike Anderson
**Food,Inc by magnolia productions
(both you can get from the RI libraries)
It really relates to this post because the excess is a sign that something is wrong, and the documentaries explain what.
Weapons of mass destruction. A waste by our standards. That is correct. But who knows how far in the future that we may need those to supplement space travel. :D
I know. Not in our lifetime. But you can never be too careful.
It's just a Puritanical guilt trip. Don't feel guilty about being able to live well. Enjoy a nice steak dinner !
Post a Comment